Whalefall


After his ill father (Josh Brolin) commits suicide by donning a weight belt and jumping off his boat, Jay Gardiner (Austin Abrams, "Weapons," 2026's "Resident Evil") goes scuba diving off the California coast in search of his remains. But when he is swallowed whole by an 80 foot sperm whale with an hour of oxygen left in his tank, it just might be his dad who saves him in "Whalefall."


Laura's Review: C-

As it turns out, spending an hour inside a whale actually gets pretty boring despite the exciting scene leading up to Jay's ingestion along with a giant squid. Cowriter (with the book's author Daniel Kraus)/director Brian Duffield's attempt to link the event to Jay's very conflicted relationship with his aggressively authoritarian dad Mitt never really jells either, the female side of the family, including Jay's mom (Elisabeth Shue, "Leaving Las Vegas") and two sisters Eva and Nan (Jane Levy, "A Little Prayer" and Emily Rudd, the "Fear Street" trilogy) so sunny, if underdeveloped, they feel like two different families. In fact, when Jay flies back home for his dad's funeral from the college in Iowa that gave him a scholarship his dad basically scoffed at because the state is land-locked, the women in the family seem barely affected by the patriarch's death. It's all very strange, as if chunks of connective tissue have been removed.

Before he jumped off his boat where his friend Hewey (John Ortiz, "Silver Linings Playbook"), obviously aware of his plans, sat fishing, Mitt left letters from his three children in a cooler which Jay finds stored in his old childhood bedroom. Jay finds his letter, but does not read it. A series of flashbacks will clue us in on the father and son's difficult relationship, dad a harsh safety absolutist scuba diver who barks at his boy before the kid's done anything wrong and who mocks Jay as a teenager for indulging a friend's wish to go to an ocean theme park for his birthday. And yet for some reason, Jay decides to venture out into the ocean to find his father's body, avoiding Hewey, who is delighted to see him, at his dad's old dive shop. Hewey does mention the exact spot Mitt left the boat, though, at the precipice of an ocean canyon.

After evading local police who appear to be shutting down access to the beach, Jay battles rough surf entering the water, Joseph Trapanese's ("The Greatest Showman") urgent violin score accentuating the danger. Cinematographer Aaron Morton (2013's "Evil Dead") treats us to some lovely underwater scenes as Jay finds his way to the chilling drop into the ocean canyon, at one point mistaking a sea sponge for a skull. But he's startled by the emergence of a giant squid, then the immense sperm whale in pursuit of it and, getting entangled with the squid's tentacles as its being consumed, hangs on for a while in the whale's mouth before being swallowed.

And we essentially spend the next hour listening to Jay grunt from within various indeterminable parts of the whale's anatomy, the giant squid's beak clamped down on his hand, the diver inexplicably sucking oxygen from his tank when he is no longer under water. More flashbacks ensue, including Jay's last, hopeless interaction with his drunken dad aboard his boat, and he begins to hear snippets of Mitt's oceanic wisdom in his head, Brolin's words modulated to sound like the voice of God raining down from the Mount. Exterior shots of the whale begin to look more and more like CGI, an attack by multiple orcas resembling a video game.

A whale fall is when the carcass of a dead whale sinks to the bottom of the ocean providing nutrients for other sea creatures, an obvious metaphor here, but while "Whalefall" began with an intriguing concept it gets completely lost at sea.



20th Century Studios releases "Whalefall" in theaters on 10/16/26.