Winnie the Pooh

Watch the current Reeling broadcast here!
(Previous editions of Reeling can be downloaded from iTunes by clicking this link.)


Laura Clifford 
Winnie the Pooh

Robin Clifford 

In the Hundred Acre Woods, there is a bear with a seriously grumbling tummy, a donkey who's lost his tail and a note from the missing Christopher Robin (Jack Boulter) which Owl (newcomer Craig Ferguson) tells his friends says that the boy has been kidnapped by the ferocious monster known as the Backson.  By day's end, friendship will prevail and a day will be well filled with adventure for "Winnie the Pooh."

Laura:
After a live action opening of Christopher Robin's bedroom, which establishes his childhood friends as stuffed animals as well as harkening back to TV's 'The Wonderful World of Disney' series, Writer (with 5 others!)/directors Stephen J. Anderson & Don Hall ("Meet the Robinsons") don't only bring us back into the beloved children's stories but into the actual A.A. Milne books.  The device, which shows the characters moving about pages, climbing letters and (almost) jumping ahead (the audience can, if they read the words), is a terrific reimagining of the classic animations and a message about reading that has a funny parallel in Owl's unadmitted weakness in the area.

The story has three main elements, all taking place on a single day punctuated continually by Pooh's lack of 'hunny.'  In the first, the Hundred Acre Woods residents have a contest to replace Eeyore's tail, but of course each attempt - a cuckoo clock, a weather vane, a balloon - has its inevitable drawbacks.  Once Christopher Robin's note is read (which, in reality, says gone for now, but back soon), Owl imagines the dreadful Backson of blue fur, sharp horns and red hair that smells like monkey feet and causes all sorts of calamaties.  Tigger (voiced by Pooh vet Jim Cummings, who also supplies the bear's bass) sets out to hunt the beast down, and, finding a spring, decides to turn Eeyore into Tigger Two.  Meanwhile Pooh and Piglet (Travis Oates) set up a 'picnic trap' and I'm sure you can see where this will all end.

John Cleese supplies the narration and there are a bevy of songs, one surreally sung as the group is animated as if in crayon, another as Rabbit's (newcomer Tom Kenny) vegetable garden becomes a boxing ring.  Pooh's behind is stuffed through the letter 'o' in honey and there is a honey mirage.  The writers even come up with a Pooh version of the 'Who's on first' routine, an adorable, funny, punny homage.

For all its delights, the new "Pooh," although charming, has a couple of drawbacks.  The songs have been better in past installments (Carly Simon was a highlight for "The Piglet Movie" and "Pooh's Hephalump Movie" whereas Zooey Deschanel's contributions here are merely pleasant) and while some of the newcomers vocal work is just fine, Bud Luckey's interpretation of Eeyore sticks out like a sore thumb, lacking that woebegone quality that's made the donkey such a favorite (was Peter Cullen really that busy voicing Optimus Prime for Michael Bay that he couldn't return?).  Still, "Winnie the Pooh's" new innovations are welcome and the film is charming from start to finish.

B+

"Winnie the Pooh" is preceded by "The Ballad of Nessie," a simplistic, old-fashioned animated short with a modern story.  Nessie and herThe Ballad of Nessie rubber duckie MacQuack are driven from their pond by developer MacFroogle, who builds a golf course empire up around them.  Nessie finally gives up trying to find a new pond and cries for weeks, creating the Loch where she will live happily ever after.  The story is told in rhyme by Scotland's own Billy Connolly and visualized in a flat two-dimensional style that harkens back to the Silly Symphonies.  B

The DVD:

The DVD is full screen (the theatrical release was a 1.85:1 aspect ratio), which isn't really a problem except for navigation, where the left arrow pointing back to the main menu might not be visible (I stopped and restarted the DVD while navigating through bonus features because of a lack of a 'Return to Main Menu' option, until, on the final feature, noticed the arrow which wasn't visible before).

Otherwise, the film offers the choice of English, subtitled English, French or Spanish before going to the disk's main menu.  There are the options for Play Movie, Scene Selection, Set Up (a repeat of language and subtitling options), Bonus Features and Sneak Peaks (Disney commercials).  Like the film itself, the Bonus Features offer something for everyone.  "Winnie the Pooh and His History Too" goes back to A. A. Milne and his inspiration, including b&w photos of the author, his son and his son's stuffed animals from the 1920's and works its way back up into the Disney fold and the present film, linked to the past by 'Pooh Guru' Burny Mathinson, who worked on the original shorts.  Deleted scenes are a trove for students of animation and filmmaking - some are presented as b&w transparencies with vocal track, others are storyboards which have been animated and one is a completed animation. Singalong and Song Selection allows one to entertain the kiddies by jumping to the songs with or without song lyrics and a bouncing red balloon.  Shorts offers the Nessie animation which played before the movie in theaters along with 'Pooh's Balloon.'  A guide to planning a Pooh nursery with baby planners Ellie and Melissa is surprisingly free of the shilling of Disney merchandise, instead offering simple, sound advice.  Don't bother clicking on the Info selection, unless you have a yen to read disclaimers.

So, as with the movie itself, a couple of quibbles, but all in all, a delight.

B+

Robin on the DVD:
After decades of being entertained by young Christopher Robin’s menagerie of stuffed animals come to life in the Hundred Acre Wood, the franchise still goes strong. The latest animation entry in the Pooh series has the denizens of the Wood in a contest to replace Eeyore’s missing tail, with a giant pot of “hunny” as reward in the Blu-Ray/DVD release of “Winnie the Pooh.”

While the theatrical release did not do well (not even making back production costs), I hope that the aftermarket drums up enough business to make some money for Disney Studios. The real winners, though, are the kids of all ages who have the good luck or good sense to watch this little gem.

The story is typical Winnie the Pooh with some crisis arising in the Hundred Acre Wood – here, Eeyore’s missing tail – and an even bigger crisis rearing its head. One of the charms of the film is the sparkling writing that uses double meanings and sophisticated sight gags that are intellectual and funny for adults but the same words will amuse kids at a different level. I also have to laud the filmmakers for maintaining the 2D tradition and not succumbing to the dreaded 3D.

The Blu-Ray/DVD two-disc release of “Winnie the Pooh”` has extras that are (as has become the case) far more extensive on the Blu-Ray disc than the DVD. The main draw for the extras is the featurette “Winnie the Pooh and His Story, too” that tells of the creation of our lovable bear and his loyal friends, beginnings in 1925 when A.A. Milne’s first Pooh tale was published in a London newspaper. The rest is history and the featurette does a fine job in bringing it to us viewers.

There are the usual deleted scenes introduced by the directors where they explain just why the scenes were deleted. Watching them, I understand the filmmaker’s thinking in cutting and trimming them. Bonus shorts include the charming “The Ballad of Nessie” and “The Mini Adventures of Winnie the Pooh.” Also included are a “sing-along with the movie” featurette and, for the baby planners out there, “Creating the Perfect Winnie-the-Pooh Nursery.” The DVD only has a small portion of the extras.

 At 63 minutes, the film is not too long, not too short, but just right. I give both the film and the Blu-Ray extras a B+.
Back To Current Show
Back To Theatrical Release Show
Next Show Previous Show
Watch the current Reeling broadcast here!

Home | Reviews and Ratings Archive  | Top 10 | Video | Crew | Article | Links

Reeling has been chosen as a Movie Review Query Engine Top Critic.

MRQE Top Critic Badge