Upside Down

Watch the current Reeling broadcast here!
(Previous editions of Reeling can be downloaded from iTunes by clicking this link.)

Robin Clifford of Reeling Reviews
Robin Clifford 
Upside Down
Laura Clifford of Reeling Reviews
Laura Clifford 

Adam and Eden met as children and their friendship continued in their adolescent years, but they never met face to face, The problem is that each is an inhabitant of a twin worl whose gravities are opposite to each other. That does not stop young love, though, when they turn things “Upside Down.” 

Robin:
Robin's review will be published on opening day, 3/15/2013.

Laura:
As a young boy Adam climbed to the top of Sage Mountain where his below world almost touches the peak of its parallel on a parallel world up above.  He meets Eden looking down at him and the youngsters begin a forbidden relationship,  Adam pulling Eden from her own gravity into his.  But they're discovered and he believes she's been killed.  10 years later, Adam (Jim Sturgess, "One Day") sees Eden (Kirsten Dunst) on TV where she is identified as an employee of Transworld, the mega-corporation which connects the two worlds, exploiting one for the benefit of the other.  Adam wrangles a job there, but in order to see Eden he has to combat his own gravity "Upside Down."

Writer/director Juan Solanas has come up with a science fiction concept and figured out the technical challenges to visualize it, but "Upside Down" is special effects in search of a story. There is no palpable passion between Adam and Eden (Shouldn't that be Purgatory and Eden or Adam and Eve?  Or better yet, neither?) and the convolutions Solanas goes through to further his plot are ludicrous.  The technical team behind "Upside Down" has done its job pretty well (the film resembles a 1990's work from Caro/Jeunet), but they've created an elaborate frame for a dull doodle.

Adam pitches his invention, a gravity-defying face cream using a family secret, to Transworld CEO Lagavullan (James Kidnie) in order to secure a Transworld position.  We have learned previously that Aunt Betty shared her knowledge of pink pollen from pink bees with Adam when she made him floating pancakes.  Just accept that this stuff exists, only Adam seems to know about it, it apes the gravity of the 'Have" world, and he decided to devote years to creating a facial cream with it.

He does this in an industrial warehouse lab under Albert (Blu Mankuma, "2012"), a seeming activist type who nonetheless supports Adam's work.  The whole 'Have" world above exploited 'Have-Not' world connected by a manmade structure is so similar to "Total Recall's," Adam is screened with a full body x-ray scanner entering Transworld.  He's hazed by his coworkers, then befriended by a suspiciously friendly above worker,  Bob Boruchowitz (Timothy Spall, "Harry Potter's" Wormtail). Bob turns out to be legit as he's publicly canned soon thereafter, but leaves Adam a parting gift - his ID badge with the security resources to gain access to Eden several floors above.

"Upside Down" is one big horizontal split screen effect, most notably within Transworld where cubicled workers exist both right side up and upside down.  A lot of attention has gone into details of gravity (each world's residents retain their own gravitational pull wherever they are), including a chandelier built upside down in the film's Cafe dos Mundos.  Of course, the obviously named Cafe makes no sense as we're told many times that commingling between the two worlds is discouraged, just as when Adam presents his facial cream to an executive board, it's been named Gravity.  Shouldn't it be called Anti-Gravity?  The whole concept of anti-matter, a method of 'balancing' in one's opposite world, is shoddy (it begins to burn up after a specified time, but one can just splash water around) and Eden's 'post teenaged accident' amnesia is a tired obstacle to the romance.

Sturgess is an appealing young actor and he evokes some amount of rooting interest, but the motions he's forced to go through are just too absurd.  Dunst is mostly intangible object, the filmmakers congratulating themselves on having her repeat her upside-down "Spider-Man" kiss (she really doesn't, she's sideways when it happens, perpendicular to Sturgess) and never has Timothy Spall's acting been so artificial.

Magical realism has a strong genesis in Latin American countries, but although Argentinean Solanas (son of Fernando E. Solanas, "Sur") can create visuals to support the genre, he needs a better foundation to build from.  "Upside Down" may be a treat for the eyes, but you'll probably be rolling them throughout most of its running time.

C-
Back To Current Show
Next Show Previous Show
Watch the current Reeling broadcast here!

Home | Reviews and Ratings Archive  | Top 10 | Video | Crew | Article | Links

Reeling has been chosen as a Movie Review Query Engine Top Critic.

MRQE Top Critic Badge