The Theory of Everything

Watch the current Reeling broadcast here!
(Previous editions of Reeling can be downloaded from iTunes by clicking this link.)

Robin Clifford of Reeling Reviews
Robin Clifford 
The Theory of Everything
Laura Clifford of Reeling Reviews
Laura Clifford 

Stephen Hawking is an intellectual icon known the world over. There has been a plethora of films and TV specials about the man for decades and his book, A Brief History of Time (1988), has been read by millions in many languages. Eddie Redmayne portrays the life of the brilliant man in “The Theory of Everything.”

Robin:
This is an amazing film of an amazing man and Redmayne gives a flawless physical (and intellectual) performance as Stephen Hawking. “The Theory of Everything” begins with the very healthy Hawking racing on bikes with his friend. The young genius, a doctoral candidate at just 20 years old, has the scientific world by the tail and he meets Jane Wilde (Felicity Jones). The young couple appears destined for a fine life until Stephen takes a bad fall.

Tests, tests and more tests reveal the very bad news: Hawking suffers from Moto neuron disease, better known as ALS (Lou Gehrig’s disease). The doctor gives young Hawking only two years before his muscles fail entirely. Stephen refuses to see Jane until she forces her way in to tell him, “I love you!” and promises to stay by his sides no matter what. She does not know it but she committed to a life that would be all consuming, with her husband the center of attention.

“The Theory of Everything” does an excellent job in presenting the science and the theories that helped form Hawking into one of the world’s preeminent scientists. The filmmakers take the complex proofs and theorems and make them understandable to us poor, dumb laymen. But, as fascinating and informative as the science of the film is, the real grab are stars Redmayne and Jones.

Redmayne’s physical performance is astounding – from the strong and healthy Ph.D. candidate at to the image of the man, electric wheel chair-bound and using a voice synthesizer, as we know him now. This change rivals Daniel Day Lewis in “My Left Foot (1989)” and John Hurt in “The Elephant Man (1980)” in the dedication of the actor to his craft. But, Eddie Redmayne achieves much more as he conveys the intelligence and sense of humor that made up Hawking’s character – a simple look from Hawking’s eyes convey volumes. His is a fully formed performance that is done with great nuance.

Felicity Jones may not have gone through the physical change and challenge of her co-star but the actress also creates a fully formed sympathetic, even empathetic, character in her Jane Hawking. You can sense the “having bit off more than she can chew” as she struggles over the years to take care of her rapidly deteriorating husband, deals with his fame and trying to complete her own doctoral thesis – and raise three children. While Redmayne’s Hawking will get the most attention at year’s end, Jones is on my short list, too.

Documentary filmmaker James Marsh (“Man on Wire (2008)” and “Project Nim (2011)”) made the jump to feature films with “Shadow Dancer” in 2012. His sophomore effort, “The Theory of Everything,” is a big leap forward for the filmmaker and is one of the best biopics since “A Beautiful Mind (2001)” and will be on many best lists. It is a remarkable film of a man who took his “just two years” and turned it into 40 and is as well known as Albert Einstein. I give it an A-.

Laura:
In 1963, Stephen Hawking (Eddie Redmayne, "Les Misérables") was a remarkable cosmology student at Cambridge University who fell in love with arts major Jane (Felicity Jones, "The Invisible Woman"). When he got the devastating news that he had neuron motor disease with a life expectancy of two years, he tried to make her go but Jane stood by him as he continued to work for decades on finding "The Theory of Everything."

In adapting Jane Hawking's "Travelling to Infinity: My Life with Stephen" (screenplay by Anthony McCarten), director James Marsh's ("Man on Wire," "Shadow Dancer") second feature is an unusually personal look at one of the great minds of science.  Eddie Redmayne's captivating performance will be compared to Daniel Day Lewis's achievement in "My Left Foot," but it is important to note how much life, joy and humor he brings to the role with little more than a cocked eyebrow, a few facial muscles and his eyes (a scene where he gets his head caught in a sweater when Jane leaves the room is delightfully relatable).  Aided by costume design (Steven Noble), Redmayne gradually fails, visibly shriveling into his wheelchair, but although there are inevitable frustrations, his handicap is balanced with the normalcy of being husband and father, right down to horseplay with his kids.  As his wife, Jones is also strong, a determined woman eventually worn down by the demands of her situation.  Here is a movie that exhibits how it is quite possible to love someone, yet turn to another for romantic renewal, a move made by both partners of the Hawking marriage.

The film is bookended by Hawking's visit to Buckingham Palace to receive an honor from the Queen, but its relational import isn't realized until film's end.  In between we see how Hawking, supported by advisor Dennis Sciama (David Thewlis, "Harry Potter's" Remus Lupin), came into prominence in his field by expanding upon Roger Penrose's black hole theory of singularity to the entire universe (and unlike "Interstellar," Hawking's theories are presented in easy to understand language).  Children arrive into the home of a not particularly prosperous academic, whose wife struggles to continue her studies along with everything else.  Her devout faith, a point of contention with her husband's work, and a need for an outlet lead her to her Church choir (at the suggestion of her mother, Beryl, played by Emily Watson).  There she meets widower Jonathan Hellyer Jones (Charlie Cox, HBO's 'Boardwalk Empire'), whose genuine desire to help quickly turns him into a third partner.  As Hawking's condition worsens, leaving him reliant on an arduous tool in order to communicate, Elaine Mason (Maxine Peake, UK TV's 'Shameless') enters the picture.  Bawdy and possessive, Elaine ignites a spark in Stephen.

The film is lushly photographed by Benoît Delhomme ("Lawless," "A Most Wanted Man"), reveling in the romanticism of Cambridge's May Ball and the cool verdancy of the English countryside. Production locations include Cambridge University grounds, the Royal Opera House (standing in for Geneva's) and Cavendish laboratory, where the atom was first split.  Art direction and costume design are impeccable, all lending to a strong sense of time and place.

Grade:  A-
Back To Current Show
Next Show Previous Show
Watch the current Reeling broadcast here!

Home | Reviews and Ratings Archive  | Top 10 | Video | Crew | Article | Links

Reeling has been chosen as a Movie Review Query Engine Top Critic.

MRQE Top Critic Badge